Pilate

The scene is Jesus on trial before Governor Pilate.  Pilate asks two questions: "Who are you?" and "What do you do?"  Jesus gives no answer that satisfies.  Why not?  Well, Pilate is asking catechism questions or informational questions.  Pilate is not asking so that Pilate will change.  Pilate has no interest in changing his way of life.  Pilate is into power, control, self-esteem, all to deal with his fears.  So Jesus gives him no answer.  If you really want to change or be changed, you cannot google some information or simply memorize a catechism answer.  Lots of us were given catechism answers whether we asked or not.  That alone won't lead you to truth or a way or a life that is deeply peaceful and Christian.  When people want to join my church, often the pedagogical method is more informational than transformational.  They are not taught how to meditate or read into the scriptures beyond the intellectual.  I think that religions can make sense without meditation.  But it won't transform you.  You have to get in touch with your interior mess for that to begin to happen.  Only then will you be open enough for change.  A Ph.D in religion won't get you there on its own.